沉默权的是非之争与正当根据(下).doc

沉默权的是非之争与正当根据(下) 鎵炬硶寰?涓婄浜? 銆愭湡鍒婂悕绉般€戙€婄幇浠ｆ硶瀛︺€? 娌夐粯鏉冪殑鏄潪涔嬩簤涓庢褰撴牴鎹紙涓嬶級 RighttoSilence锛欴ebateinAlternativeJurisdictionsandJustifications 銆愪綔鑰呫€戝瓩闀挎案銆愪綔鑰呭崟浣嶃€戣タ鍗楁斂娉曞ぇ瀛? 銆愬垎绫汇€戝垜浜嬭瘔璁兼硶銆愬叧閿瘝銆戞矇榛樻潈锛屼簤璁猴紝姝ｅ綋鏍规嵁锛岃瘔璁间环鍊硷紝鐩稿鎬? 銆愭枃绔犵紪鐮併€?001鈥?397锛?001锛?4鈥?055鈥?9 銆愭枃鐚爣璇嗙爜銆慉銆愭€绘湡鍙枫€?16 銆愭湡鍒婂勾浠姐€?001骞淬€愭湡鍙枫€? 銆愰〉鐮併€?5 銆愭憳瑕併€? 鑻辩編鍥藉鍏充簬娌夐粯鏉冪殑浜夎骞舵病鏈夊畬鍏ㄥ惁瀹氭矇榛樻潈鐨勬剰鎬濓紝鑰屽彧鏄娌夐粯鏉冪殑鍏蜂綋瑙勫垯鏈変笉鍚屾剰瑙併€傛矇榛樻潈鏄竴椤规湁鍏呭垎閬撳痉鍩虹鐨勪釜浜烘潈鍒╋紝瀹冩棦鏈夐噸瑕佺殑璇夎浠峰€硷紝鍙堝彲鑳介渶瑕佷粯鍑轰竴瀹氱殑浠ｄ环锛屼絾涓€浜涘浗瀹跺嚭浜庝繚鎶ゅ叕鍏卞埄鐩婄殑闇€瑕佸瀹冭繘琛岀殑闄愬埗鍧囬檮甯︽湁涓ユ牸鐨勬潯浠讹紝娌夐粯鏉冪殑鍩烘湰绮剧骞舵病鏈夊彈鍒版崯瀹炽€傚潥鎸佸拰鍙戝睍娌夐粯鏉冨埗搴︼紝浠嶇劧鏄綋浠婁笘鐣屽垜浜嬪徃娉曢鍩熺殑涓€绉嶅熀鏈秼鍔裤€? 銆愯嫳鏂囨憳瑕併€? WhiletherighttosilencehaslongbeenasubjectofheateddebateinbothUKandtheUSA锛宯obodyhasadvancedanarbitraryargumentastoabolishitcompletely锛嶪tsmoralbasis锛宩ustificationsandproceduralvalueshavebeenwidelyrecognized锛嶴trictprovisosareattachedtolimitationsoftherightoutofconcernforpublicinterests锛嶵hebasicinternationaltrendliesinnotlimitingbutfirmlyguaranteeingthefundamentalright锛? 銆愬唴瀹广€? 涓夈€佹矇榛樻潈鐨勬褰撴牴鎹? 銆€銆€浠庝笂杩板叧浜庢矇榛樻潈鐨勪簤璁轰腑鍙互鐪嬪嚭锛屼簤璁哄悇鏂归兘娌℃湁瑕佸畬鍏ㄥ惁瀹氭矇榛樻潈鐨勬剰鎬濓紝鑰屼富瑕佹槸瀵规矇榛樻潈鐨勫叿浣撹鍒欐湁涓嶅悓鎰忚銆傞偅涔堬紝娌夐粯鏉冪┒绔熸湁娌℃湁姝ｅ綋鏍规嵁锛熷鏋滄湁锛屽叾姝ｅ綋鏍规嵁鍙堟槸浠€涔堬紵杩欐槸鍦ㄧ‘绔嬫矇榛樻潈涔嬪墠蹇呴』瑙ｅ喅鐨勪袱涓噸澶х悊璁洪棶棰樸€傚墠涓€涓棶棰樹腑鎵€瑕佹帰璁ㄧ殑鏄細闈㈠鏉ヨ嚜瀹樻柟鐨勮闂垨璁棶锛屽珜鐤戜汉銆佽鍛婁汉鍦ㄩ亾寰蜂笂鏄湁鍥炵瓟鐨勪箟鍔¤繕鏄湁淇濇寔娌夐粯鐨勬潈鍒╋紵鍚庝竴涓棶棰樻墍娑夊強鐨勫唴瀹规槸锛氬摢浜涙牴鎹墠鏄矇榛樻潈鐨勭湡姝ｅ熀纭€锛熻繖鍙堢壍娑夎嫳缇庡垽渚嬩笌鐞嗚涓粡甯歌璁虹殑浠ヤ笅涓€浜涢棶棰橈細娌夐粯鏉冧笌瑷€璁鸿嚜鐢辨潈銆佷釜浜鸿嚜娌诲拰闅愮鏉冩槸浠€涔堝叧绯伙紵娌夐粯鏉冧笌鏃犵姜鎺ㄥ畾鍘熷垯鏈夋棤蹇呯劧鑱旂郴锛熶笌杩欎簺闂鏈夊叧鐨勬槸娌夐粯鏉冪殑璇夎浠峰€奸棶棰橈細娌夐粯鏉冭兘澶熶績杩涜瘔璁肩殑鍏杩涜鍚楋紵瀹冩湁鍔╀簬鍑嗙‘鍦板尯鍒姜涓庨潪缃紝鐗瑰埆鏄繚鎶ゆ棤缃殑浜哄悧锛熷瀹冪殑纭鏄惁闇€瑕佷粯鍑烘矇閲嶇殑浠ｄ环锛熷浜庤繖浜涢棶棰橈紝瑗挎柟瀛﹁€呭潎宸叉湁杩囪鐪熺殑璁ㄨ锛屼絾鎰忚涓嶅畬鍏ㄧ粺涓€锛屽湪鏌愪簺鏂归潰鐢氳嚦瀛樺湪涓ラ噸鍒嗘銆備笅闈㈢粨鍚堣繖浜涗笉鍚屾剰瑙侊紝瀵逛笂杩伴棶棰樹緷娆″姞浠ユ帰璁ㄣ€? 銆€銆€锛堜竴锛夋矇榛樼殑閬撳痉鏉冨埄涓庡洖绛旂殑閬撳痉涔夊姟涔嬭鲸 銆€銆€瀵逛簬瀹樻柟鐨勮闂垨璁棶锛屽珜鐤戜汉銆佽鍛婁汉鏈夋棤鍥炵瓟鐨勯亾寰蜂箟鍔★紵瀵规锛屾湁鈥滆偗瀹氳鈥濅笌鈥滃惁瀹氳鈥濅袱绉嶆埅鐒朵笉鍚岀殑绛旀銆? 銆€銆€鈥滆偗瀹氳鈥濊涓哄珜鐤戜汉銆佽鍛婁汉鏈夊洖绛旂殑閬撳痉涔夊姟锛屾矇榛樻潈涓庢櫘閫氱殑閬撳痉鏍囧噯鐩告姷瑙︺€傝竟娌佸浜庢矇榛樻潈鐨勬壒鍒ゃ€佸垜浜嬫硶淇敼濮斿憳浼氱11娆℃姤鍛婁腑涓诲紶鐨勨€滃父璇嗚鈥濅互鍙婄編鍥藉紬鍏板痉鍒╂硶瀹樼殑鎰忚锛岄兘鏄繖绉嶈鐐圭殑浠ｈ〃銆傝繖绉嶈鐐瑰綋鐒跺苟涓嶆槸涓诲紶瀹樻柟鍙互姣棤鏍规嵁鍦版€€鐤戜竴涓嚜鐢辨皯锛岃€