如何阅读论文how to evaluate a paper讲解.ppt

Anhui Normal University 伍永钢 Why do we need evaluate? Thorough understanding Find new hint Six important questions 1. What questions does the paper address? 2. What are the main conclusions of the paper? 3. What evidence supports those conclusions? 4. Do the data actually support the conclusions? 5. What is the quality of the evidence? 6. Why are the conclusions important? Six important questions 1. What questions does the paper address? 2. What are the main conclusions of the paper? 3. What evidence supports those conclusions? 4. Do the data actually support the conclusions? 5. What is the quality of the evidence? 6. Why are the conclusions important? 1. What questions does the paper address? Different research types Descriptive Comparative Analytical Different research types Descriptive Comparative Analytical Descriptive research Early stage A new system Descriptive research DBPs（消毒副产物） Innovative reactor Different research types Descriptive Comparative Analytical Comparative research Middle stage How general ? Comparative research DBPs conditions ; concentration; etc Innovative reactor substrate ; operation conditions; etc Different research types Descriptive Comparative Analytical Analytical research Latter stage Hypotheses or model Analytical research DBPs hypotheses ; mechanism; etc Innovative reactor model ; feedback from application; etc 1. What questions does the paper address? Question type From abstract Results Six important questions 1. What questions does the paper address? 2. What are the main conclusions of the paper? 3. What evidence supports those conclusions? 4. Do the data actually support the conclusions? 5. What is the quality of the evidence? 6. Why are the conclusions important? 2. What are the main conclusions of the paper? Find it from Conclusion and Abstract Interesting or amazing or important etc Read paper with question in mind Six important questions 1. What q