科技论文教学课件-如何撰写学术论文.pptVIP

一个提出反对意见的例子 Reviewer #4 clearly didnt read my paper carefully enough. Either that or this reviewer doesnt know anything about the field! How should I respond during the rebuttal period? Please dont say: If reviewer #4 had just taken the time to read my paper carefully, she would have realized that our algorithm was rotation invariant. Instead say: Unfortunately, Section #4 must not have been as clear as we had hoped because Reviewer #4 didnt understand that our algorithm was rotation invariant and he was therefore skeptical about the general applicability of our approach. Here is a revised version of the second paragraph in Section 4, which should clear up this confusion. 《文献检索与论文写作》 所有作者都被拒绝过，不只是你！ 尽量去了解退稿的原因。 要知道编辑和审稿人已经在你的论文上花费了不少时间，而你也从中学到了有益的东西。要重视他们的意见。 重新审视你的论文，想一想是否值得投往其他刊物。 如果你认为值得，要像写新论文一样重新准备——从反复阅读“新目标”的Guide for Authors开始。 退稿: 别太沮丧，这不是世界末日！ 《文献检索与论文写作》 你的论文很有可能“落入”同一个审稿人(甚至编辑)手中。 我们的建议： 在 cover letter说明此文曾被退稿，并指明期刊名。 说明退稿意见，并逐一详细回复。体现你对审稿意见的重视。 解释说明为什么选择这个期刊重新投稿。例如，你认为你的论文更适合这本期刊；或者你在读了这本期刊的某篇综述后修改了你的论文；等等。 切勿不加修改即投往他刊！ 《文献检索与论文写作》 怎样才能得到“Acceptance”？ Attention to details Check and double check your work Consider the reviews English must be as good as possible Presentation is important Take your time with revision Acknowledge those who have helped you New, original and previously unpublished Critically evaluate your own manuscript Ethical rules must be obeyed – Nigel John Cook, Editor-in-Chief, Ore Geology Reviews 《文献检索与论文写作》 * [翻译吧] I pasted on this page as an example of citation in discussion. Why is citing references in discussion necessary? Because References cited in this section are the most essential one to your own work! Your reviewers are probably authors of these references. This way you are actually discussing with your reviewers. Another good reason is that, if one author notices that his own work has been substantially discussed by you in discussion section, he will be very interested in your argument, and, it’s very likely that he