法学专家意见书的法律分析民商法专业论文.docx

paper and points out some rough and concrete measures to regulate the legists opinion， mainly including the way how did legist point out the law opinion, when did the legist opinion showed out and the proceeding of legist?s opinion paper. Keyword: legist, legist?s opinion paper, judicial authority, Judicial independent， regulations on the opinion paper of legist 目 录 中文摘要........................................................................................................ I 英文摘要....................................................................................................... II 前 言 ........................................................................................................1 1 法学专家意见书的概念解析 ...................................................................2 1.1 法学专家意见书的概念 ..............................................................................2 1.2 法学专家意见书的性质 ..............................................................................3 1.2.1 法学专家意见书不是我国的法定证据形式 ..............................................3 1.2.2 法学专家意见书与律师代理词的区别 ....................................................4 1.2.3 法学专家意见书与专家意见证据的区别 .................................................4 1.3 法学专家意见书产生的原因 ........................................................................5 1.3.1 当事人追求自身诉讼利益的最大化 .......................................................6 1.3.2 司法人员对自身的职业能力缺乏信心 ....................................................6 1.3.3 法学专家积极介入司法实践 ................................................................7 1.3.4 我国司法权威不足为家法律意见的产生提供了土壤 ..................................8 2 法学专家意见书的学理分析 ................................................................. 10 2.1 法学专家在法律发展中的贡献与定位 .......................................................... 10 2.2 法学专家意见书体现法学精英主义 ............................................................. 12 2.3 法学专家行使言论自由与监督的权利 .......................................................... 12 2.4 法学专家意见书是重实体轻程序的副产品 ....................................